Finding comparable homes for your Cook County appeal
Updated Fri, Nov 20, 2026
Pick 3 to 10 homes in your Assessor neighborhood with the same class and style, within about 20% of your size and 15 years of your age, then compare building assessment per square foot. If yours is clearly higher than the middle of them, that is a "lack of uniformity" appeal.
What to do this week
- Find your 14-digit PIN on your tax bill or reassessment notice.
- Look up your home's recorded size, age and style, and fix anything wrong first.
- Choose similar homes with lower building assessments per square foot, and write down their PINs.
What the Board of Review means by comparable
The Board compares the building part of the assessment, divided by building square feet, against similar homes nearby. Land is usually assessed the same way across a block, so the building number is where differences show. Same neighborhood code, same property class (for example 2-05, a two-story home over 62 years old), similar size, similar age and similar construction are what make a home "similar".
The Assessor's rule of thumb, published on its appeals page, is that an assessment within about 10 percent of similar homes is considered fair. Owners who win usually show a clear gap, not a few cents.
How to choose comps that hold up
- Same neighborhood and class. Comps from another neighborhood code are easy for the Board to dismiss.
- Close in size and age. Within about 20% of your building square feet and 15 years of your year built.
- Lower per square foot, not just lower overall. A smaller home with a lower total is not evidence; a same-size home with a lower assessment per square foot is.
- Several, not one. Five to ten good comps make the middle value hard to argue with. Leave out obvious oddballs.
- Show the arithmetic. For each home: PIN, size, year, building assessment, and building assessment divided by size. Then the middle value times your size is the value to ask for.
A real example from Bremen Township
A 1955 two-story of 1,708 sq ft in Bremen has a building assessment of $12,783, or $7.48 per square foot. Six two-story homes in the same neighborhood, built 1948 to 1956 and 1,431 to 1,809 sq ft, have a middle value of $5.94 per square foot. At the middle rate the building would be assessed about $10,153, a cut of about $2,630, which at that home's 2025 tax rate is roughly $1,620 a year. One of the six is assessed higher than the home; good evidence includes it rather than hiding it. Two county records at the same address count as one home.
House numbers and PINs are hidden here. See the whole sample pack.
Doing it with the county's tools, or with ours
The Assessor's site lists comparable properties for a PIN, and the county map viewer shows nearby parcels, but you have to page through and do the per-square-foot maths yourself. Our free check does that step for your home in seconds and shows where it sits among its neighbors. The $49 pack adds the PINs, addresses and the value to ask for, laid out for the Board of Review.
Questions
How many comparables do I need?
Can I use homes that sold recently?
What if the county has my size wrong?
See how your home compares
Free, using the county's own records. No sign-up.
Sources
Cook County Board of Review, "How to present a case" and its uniformity explanation; Cook County Assessor appeals page; Assessor 2026 values (uzyt-m557) and characteristics (x54s-btds) for the example. Not affiliated with Cook County.